I've been trying to write a review for this book ever since I finished it yesterday, and honestly, I'm really not sure how to review this book.
I can see why people dislike this book (I mean, Sutter isn't the most likable character), but then again, I can also see how people really like this book (it is fairly realistic).
I liked it. A lot more than I expected to, honestly.
I can't really write a full blown review on this book, but I can list what I did and didn't like.What I liked:
Tharp has perfected the teenage voice. There is no doubt about that. Sutter, though unlikeable at times, actually comes off as a teenager living in the now as opposed to worrying about the future.
The relationship between Sutter and Aimee. Okay, so their ending isn't necessarily a happy one, but it is the right one.
It's a sad ending, but at the same time, it's perfect.
The humor. There is a lot of pain within both Sutter and Aimee, but Tharp manages to balance the pain and the humor rather well.What I didn't like:
Sutter at times, honestly. I get that he is a bit of an alcoholic, I do, and at times you felt sorry for him, but some of his actions and some of his words really just made want to shake him - especially when it came to Aimee. Thankfully the ending redeemed him, somewhat.
The relationship between Sutter and Aimee. Yeah, I know I said I liked this, but there were also some issues I had with it. He wanted to save her, but there were times when others tried to show him that he was ruining her, and he just blew it off.
She was such a broken character, and well, he definitely did take advantage of her at times, and I didn't care for that.
Would I recommend it? Sure. It is definitely worth a read, plus, the movie is getting rave reviews, just know that this book definitely isn't for everyone. I'd say it is more upper YA.